I.League's Legal Loophole: When Indonesian Football Has No Point-Deduction Law
**Core answer**: I.League confirmed on October 21, 2026, that no regulation exists for point-deduction sanctions related to supporter riots in the Indonesian Super League. The league imposed a Rp30 million fine and a half-season away-travel ban on The Jakmania after the Persita 3-2 Persija match on October 17, 2026. **Key facts**: - Persita defeated Persija 3-2 in Week 5 of the 2026/2027 Super League at Banten International Stadium on October 17, 2026. - I.League fined Persija Rp30 million and banned The Jakmania from away travel for half a season. - Ferry Paulus stated the PSSI Disciplinary Code has no provision for point deductions for supporter riots. - I.League is open to pushing a special regulation for heavier sanctions, but no timeline or draft exists. - A prior incident involved The Jakmania attacking the Persib Bandung U-18 bus. **Source attribution**: VIVA (Indonesian media outlet), press conference of October 21, 2026. Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A**: Q: Can I.League deduct points from Persija for supporter violence? A: No. The current PSSI Disciplinary Code does not include point-deduction provisions for supporter riots. Q: What sanctions were actually imposed on Persija? A: A Rp30 million fine and a half-season away-travel ban on The Jakmania supporter group. Q: Will I.League introduce a point-deduction rule in the future? A: I.League stated it is open to pushing a special regulation, but no timeline, draft, or consultation process has been announced.
Press Conference of October 21, 2026, Jakarta
Ferry Paulus stood before dozens of camera lenses, holding the Komdis report. He did not read it. He simply said one sentence that silenced the room: "We cannot deduct points from Persija because the law does not allow it."
Four days earlier, on October 17, 2026, at Banten International Stadium, Persita defeated Persija 3-2 in Week 5 of the 2026/2027 Super League. An away defeat for Indonesia's biggest club. And as an unavoidable law of football in the archipelago, defeat on the pitch brings violence in the stands.
But the story is not about the match. It lies in the legal gap that the President Director of I.League has just acknowledged publicly.
Context: A Football Industry Built on Faith
I have followed Southeast Asian football for over two decades, from the days when V.League was a semi-professional competition to when Thai League emerged as a continental force. Indonesia has always been a special case. This country has the most passionate fan base in the region, the most tightly organized supporter groups, and the most fragile football governance system.
The 2026/2027 Super League is the third season under I.League, the competition operator separated from PSSI. This separation was promoted as a step toward professionalization, allowing the league to operate on market logic rather than administrative logic. But like all half-measures, it created a gray zone: the league has money, brand, audiences, but no independent legal authority to shape its own rules.
Supporter violence is not a new phenomenon in Indonesia. It is part of the football culture here, in both literal and figurative senses. Since the 1990s, groups like The Jakmania (Persija), Bobotoh (Persib), and Aremania (Arema) have built collective identity tied to defending their colors — sometimes with fists and bats. Violence is part of the ritual, of how groups assert territory and status.
What is remarkable is that no one in Indonesian football administration wants to admit this. They call it "incidents," "behavior of overly zealous individuals," "stadium security issues." The language is curated to avoid confronting a structural truth: supporter violence is the inevitable consequence of a football culture built on group antagonism, nurtured by the absence of conflict resolution mechanisms, and tolerated by a disciplinary system without teeth.
Core: Anatomy of a Legal Gap
When I read I.League's announcement about the Persita-Persija incident, I was struck by a detail that most Indonesian media overlooked: the sanction for Persija was 30 million Rupiah, equivalent to approximately 1,800 to 2,000 USD. For a club with the largest fan base in Southeast Asia and one of Indonesia's most valuable sports brands, this amount is comparable to the cost of a team dinner.
But the real story is not in the number.
Ferry Paulus admitted that Komdis — PSSI's Disciplinary Committee — has no specific provision for deducting points from clubs whose supporters cause disturbances. This means: while the public and media had assumed that Persija would lose points due to The Jakmania's violence, the league operator never had a law to do so.
The gap between public expectation and legal reality is a serious fracture in Indonesian football governance. It reveals a system where fans believe they are playing by one set of rules, while the operators know that set of rules does not exist.
Look at the structure of the sanctions. Komdis applied two measures: a 30 million Rupiah fine and a ban on The Jakmania traveling away for half a season. The second measure sounds severe, but on closer analysis, it is a punishment targeting supporters, not the club. It strips the supporter group's right to attend, but creates no competitive loss for Persija. The team retains its points, can still compete for continental spots, can still win the title.
This is the crux I want to emphasize: the Indonesian football disciplinary system prices misconduct in money, not points. It treats supporter violence as a security issue requiring remediation costs, not a sporting issue requiring competitive measures. And by pricing violence at 30 million Rupiah — about 1,800 USD — the system tells clubs: if your supporters cause trouble, you can buy silence for the price of a smartphone.
But wait. Before concluding that I.League is condoning violence, we need to look at the other side of the equation.
Ferry Paulus said I.League is "open to pushing a special regulation" on point deductions. He said this not as an empty promise, but as a policy signal. And in a context where the public is outraged, media is asking questions, and supporter groups are waiting, this signal carries more weight than a routine press release.
But I keep a notebook, and it does not record victories. My notebook records what people do not say. And what I.League does not say is: there is no specific timeline, no draft legislation, no consultation process, no transitional mechanism. Only one word: "open." In political language, "open" is the furthest word from "will do."
If I.League were truly serious, they would have published a roadmap. They would have invited stakeholders to participate in drafting. They would have specified whether the new regulation would apply from next season or 2028. The silence on these details is not accidental. It is a communication strategy: making the public believe reform is coming, while in reality nothing is committed.
Another notable point: there is no mention whatsoever of PSSI's role in the rule-making process. In Indonesia, Komdis is a PSSI body, not an I.League body. Any change to the disciplinary code requires federation approval. I.League cannot create point-deduction law on its own. So when Ferry Paulus says "open to pushing," whom is he pushing? PSSI? The government? Or is he simply gauging public reaction before committing to anything?
Evidence from the Past: A Pattern, Not an Incident
To understand why this case matters, it must be placed in a broader context. I.League mentions a prior event: The Jakmania's bus attack on the Persib Bandung U-18 team. This is not a minor incident. This is organized violence, targeted, and highly symbolic — aimed at the youth team of a fierce rival.
When a supporter group attacks a bus carrying young players, they are not just causing trouble. They are sending a message: the war between supporter groups has no limits, and it will be passed from generation to generation. This is how violence reproduces itself.
I.League's inclusion of this event in the same context as the violence at Banten International Stadium is not coincidental. It shows they are aware of the pattern: supporter violence in Indonesia is not a transient phenomenon but a structural feature of the country's football culture. And if it is structural, then the response must also be structural.
But here is the paradox: precisely because violence is structural, a point-deduction rule — if adopted — would have enormous impact. It would turn every Persija-Persib derby into a legal gamble, where supporter groups could deliberately cause trouble to damage opponents. It would create perverse incentives: instead of preventing violence, supporter groups might encourage it as a competitive weapon.
This is the risk I.League has not publicly addressed. And this is why a point-deduction rule, if poorly designed, could do more harm than good.
Contrarian Angle: Why I.League Is Right Not to Have a Law
This story is often told in a simple template: I.League is weak, dares not punish Persija, allows supporter violence to continue. But this template ignores an important legal reality: the principle of nulla poena sine lege — no punishment without law.
Ferry Paulus invoked this principle correctly. He said punishment "must have a firm regulatory basis." This is not evasion. This is the foundation of any legal system. If I.League deducted points from Persija without a specific provision, that decision would be overturned on appeal. And it would set a dangerous precedent: clubs could be punished at the whim of operators, not by law.
Here, I want to pose the reverse question: does the Indonesian public really want I.League to violate basic legal principles just to satisfy momentary anger? Are they willing to accept a system where disciplinary decisions are made arbitrarily, as long as they target the right enemies?
The answer may not be comfortable. But it is the question that needs to be asked.
However, I.League not having a law does not mean I.League is innocent. The difference between "cannot punish" and "has not built the tools to punish" is enormous. I.League has operated the Super League for three seasons. In those three seasons, they have witnessed countless supporter violence incidents. They have seen supporter groups challenge each other, attack each other, and even attack youth teams. So why until now — October 2026 — do they still not have a law?
The answer may lie in comfort. A system without point-deduction law is easier to operate. You do not have to make difficult decisions. You do not have to face pressure from big clubs. You just fine, ban away travel, and declare that you are "considering reform." Meanwhile, violence continues, and broadcast revenue keeps flowing in.
System, Not Individual: Who Benefits When This Gap Exists?
When analyzing scandals in football, I always remind myself of one principle: my task is to present evidence, not to deliver moral judgments. And the evidence in this case points to one conclusion: the legal gap is not an accident — it is a feature of the system.
Look at the incentive structure. I.League is an organization that operates a competition. Its success is measured by attendance, broadcast revenue, and the commercial appeal of the league. Supporter violence harms these metrics — but only to a certain extent. Derbies still sell out. Supporter groups still create the fervent atmosphere that television wants to broadcast. And the big clubs — those with the most aggressive supporter groups — are still the league's most valuable brands.
If I.League creates a point-deduction rule, they will face a political problem: pleasing one supporter group means angering another. And if they deduct points from a big club like Persija, they could lose part of their audience. In football, audience is money. And money is everything.
This is not a hypothesis. This is the logic of every professional sports league in the world. The Premier League does not deduct points from Manchester United because their supporters sing offensive songs. La Liga does not deduct points from Real Madrid because their ultras cause trouble. Leagues protect their commercial assets. And their biggest commercial assets are their biggest clubs.
I.League is no exception. They will talk about reform. They will hold meetings. They will publish studies. But when it comes time to make a decision — when they must choose between justice and revenue — they will choose revenue. Not because they are bad. But because the system is designed for them to do so.
The Second Blood Sample Does Not Lie
Throughout my investigative career, I have learned a lesson I apply to every case: people can lie, but systems always leave traces.
In this case, the traces are in the numbers themselves. Look at the 30 million Rupiah sanction. If I.League were truly serious about combating supporter violence, they would have applied a fine proportional to Persija's financial scale. They would have applied a fine that could impact the club's budget. They would have applied a fine that would make sponsors take notice.
Instead, they chose 30 million Rupiah. A number small enough that Persija can pay it without thinking. A number large enough that I.League can claim they acted. A number designed to balance public pressure and commercial interest.
This is how the system lies. It does not lie with words. It lies with numbers selected to look serious but are in fact harmless.
And this is why I believe a point-deduction rule, if adopted, will not solve the problem. It will only shift from one form of accountability exemption to another. Big clubs will find ways to bargain. Supporter groups will find ways to circumvent the law. And I.League will find ways to delay difficult decisions by establishing study committees.
The problem is not the lack of law. The problem is the lack of political will to enforce the law fairly.
Takeaway: Responsibility Does Not Belong to One Name
The story of I.League and the legal gap in handling supporter violence does not end by finding one person responsible. It does not end by firing Ferry Paulus or dissolving Komdis. It ends — if it can end — by acknowledging that the problem is structural.
A system without point-deduction law is a system designed to fail. Not because its operators are incompetent. But because the system is built to protect certain interests, and those interests do not include confronting supporter violence seriously.
If I could send one message to those running Indonesian football, it would be: do not ask why there is no law. Ask who benefits when there is no law. And when you find the answer, ask why they are still in power.
Indonesian football will not change just because of a press conference. It will change when fans — those who truly love this sport — understand that they are playing by a set of rules that does not exist. And when they stop believing in promises of reform, that is when real pressure begins.
Moscow never stops being cold, but secrets are always warm. And in Jakarta, the secrets of how football is run are still waiting to be exposed.
